Monday, May 14, 2007

Pope set to bring back Latin Mass in face of opposition

The TimesOnline has a story, Pope set to bring back Latin Mass in face of opposition which makes a number of statements. One is that the Pope will issue the Motu Proprio despite opposition.

The author states that "the document had been expected earlier but is understood to have been delayed after a seven-page document of objections by German bishops was sent to the Pope."

That's certainly a possibility, but one really doesn't know for certain.

More interesting are some of the claims made in the piece, such as, "when the permission is published, it is thought likely to exclude prayer for the conversion of the Jews."

This seems highly unlikely. I can't imagine it will be anything but the 1962 Missal in the form as it is already used by the FSSP et al. As well, conversion, it must be stated again, is different than hate or anti-semitism. This objection to prayers for conversion is not rooted in a Christian understanding of evangelization, nor of the place of Christ in our salvation. If anything, such a concern might be addressed by explaining and clarifying such.

More to the point however is this bold bit of speculation:

"It could also include an “opt-out clause”, allowing bishops to prohibit it at a local level, which would placate both the German and the modernist French bishops."

This seems highly unlikely. It would destroy the likely purpose of the motu proprio and effectively keep the present status quo. It would make little sense for the Pope to do such, because if such were acceptable, the present situation would be sufficient, and really all that would be needed is continuing encouragement for generosity for a special permission. But evidently the Holy Father does not think the present situation satisfactory, and likely for a number of reasons.

If, as the Pope has said in a number of writings, the effective sidelining of the Roman liturgical tradition is highly problematic and undesireable, why would he set in force actions to correct that, while at the same time allowing a clause which would allow for the same side-lining to occur yet again, potentially neutralizing the entire document?

To be honest, this speculation comes off as a form of lobbying through the media, possibly on the part of those within the Church who would like for there to be such a clause, and who are therefore trying to shape things in that direction. We've seen such before.

I wouldn't get terribly excited by this speculation. It seems quite inconsistent and very unlikely.

More recent articles:


My Interview on Holy Week with Christopher Jasper on Pipes with Augustine
A few days ago, I gave an interview to Mr Christopher Jasper, the founder and director of the online Gregorian Chant Academy. The main subject of our interview is the various reforms of Holy Week, but we touched several related issues as well, such as the mindset of the whole project of liturgical reform in the 20th century. I make bold to suggest ...

The Offertory Incensation, Part I
Lost in Translation #122After preparing and offering the gifts and himself, the priest blesses the incense. As he places three spoonfuls of incense onto a live coal, he says: Per intercessiónem beáti Michaélis Archángeli, stantis a dextris altáris incénsi, et ómnium electórum suórum, incénsum istud dignétur Dóminus benedícere, et in odórem suavit...

Music for Lent: The Media Vita
The hour of Compline is far more variable in the Dominican Office than in the Roman, often changing the antiphon of the psalms, the hymn, and the antiphon of the Nunc dimittis. This was true of most medieval Uses, and especialy in Lent, a season in which the Dominican Use brings forth some its best treasures. The most famous of these is certainly ...

Tenebrae: The Church’s “Office of the Dead” for Christ Crucified
The Catholic Institute of Sacred Music cordially invites you to the final event of its 2024–2025 Public Lecture and Concert Series.Tenebrae: The Church’s “Office of the Dead” for Christ CrucifiedLecture by James Monti (Dunwoodie, New York)Saturday, April 12, 10:00 a.m. PDT (1 p.m. EDT)From at least as far back as the sixth century, the Church has b...

The Twentieth Anniversary of the Death of Pope St John Paul II
Today marks the twentieth anniversary of the death of Pope St John Paul II, whose reign of almost 26½ years is the third longest in history, after those of St Peter (traditionally said to be 32 years, one less than Our Lord’s earthy life), and Blessed Pius IX (31 years and nearly 8 months.) In the days leading up to his funeral, roughly 4 million p...

On the Sanctification of Time
In “Processing through the Courts of the Great King,” I spoke of how the many courtyards and chambers of the King’s palace prior to his throne room, or the many precincts and rooms of the Temple leading up to the Holy of Holies, could be a metaphor of a healthy Catholic spiritual life that culminates in the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass, but surrounds...

“Now About the Midst of the Feast” - Christ the Teacher in the Liturgy of Lent
Today’s Gospel in the Roman Rite, John 7, 14-31, begins with the words “Now about the midst of the feast”, referring to the feast of Tabernacles, which St John had previously mentioned in verse 2 of the same chapter. And indeed, the whole of this chapter is set within the context of this feast.The Expulsion of the Money-Changers from the Temple, th...

The Apple of Her Eye
“The Lord God planted a garden in Eden, which is in the east, and there he put the man he had fashioned. From the soil, the Lord God caused to grow every kind of tree, enticing to look at and good to eat, with the tree of life in the middle of the garden, and the tree of the knowledge of good and evil.” (Gen. 2, 8-9) This 17th century painting...

The Exposition of the Holy Lance at St Peter’s Basilica
The YouTube channel of EWTN recently published a video about the exposition of the Holy Lance at St Peter’s basilica on the first Saturday of Lent. This was formerly done on the Ember Friday, which was long kept as the feast of the Holy Lance and Nails, but since this feast is no longer observed, the exposition of the relic has been transferred to ...

The Feast and Sunday of St John Climacus
In the Byzantine liturgy, each of the Sundays of Lent has a special commemoration attached to it. The first Sunday is known as the Sunday of Orthodoxy, because it commemorates the defeat of iconoclasm and the restoration of the orthodox belief in the use of icons; many churches have a procession in which the clergy and faithful carry the icons, as...

For more articles, see the NLM archives: