Sunday, July 08, 2007

Question about fluidity from Extraordinary to Ordinary

For years, musicians have parsed the General Instruction for guidance on how to manage the musical problem in the ordinary form. To be sure, the GIRM is a reliable guide as compared with the really-existing liturgy found in most Catholic parishes. But what if the musicians want to push forward and manner more progressive than the GIRM seems inclined to support?

Some concrete examples: a polyphonic Sanctus, which is not forbidden by law but seems vaguely discouraged by the GIRM; introducing additional Sequences besides those listed in the existing liturgical books; using the Graduale instead of the Responsorial Psalm; dropping the Mysterium Fidei; using a Kyrie in addition to the Asperges; moving the Asperges to before the Introit, etc. All of these practices are known and frequent in some parishes advancing toward the ideal but they seem not to benefit from overt backing in the GIRM.

Now, a frequent mistake is to regard the GIRM as normatively prescriptive rather than descriptive, and I gather from Canon lawyers that this is just an error. The GIRM is to be treated as a description of liturgical events in the manner in which they are expected proceed, but not a manual of rubrics that is somehow binding in a normative sense. Still, we are left without much guidance unless we look to tradition on these matters, that is to say, we look to the extraordinary form of the Roman Rite, rather than seeing the ordinary form as somehow hermetically sealed off from liturgical practice through the ages.

My question concerns the implications of the Motu Proprio on these matters. It seems to be Benedict's impulse to encourage a kind of two-way borrowing from the extraordinary to the ordinary form. The USCCB is already saying that the old rule against "mixing rites" no longer applies since the old and new are to be seen not as separate rites but as two forms of the same rite. Doesn't this suggest, then, a greater degree of liberality concerning the ordinary form than we have previously supposed? What happens, for example, to the dubium from the CDW that ruled against new form celebrations employing the old form offertory prayers? Are we to see that as entirely overruled?

Other questions present themselves. How far can we go with this? Can Introibo ad altare dei be restored? The last Gospel? Can the extraordinary Roman Canon be now placed within the new form structure? What about the old formula for distributing communion? What are the boundaries?

My apologies if these questions are a bit naive. Maybe the answer is no, no way, that's absurd, can't be done. And yet Benedict's document seems to encourage a much greater borrowing in both directions. E.g, the MP suggests that new prefaces and new saints be added in the extraordinary form on the general principle that "the two Forms of the usage of the Roman Rite can be mutually enriching."

Perhaps another way to ask the question: what the prevailing norms for borrowing between two forms of the same Rite? Is there precedent or are we exploring a completely new world here?

More recent articles:


An Interview with Fr Uwe Michael Lang on Liturgy
I am sure that our readers will enjoy this interview with the liturgical scholar Fr Uwe Michael Lang of the London Oratory, which was recently published on the YouTube channel of the Totus Tuus Apostolate. It covers a wide range of subjects: Pope Benedict’s teaching on the liturgy, the liturgical abuses in the post-Conciliar period and our own time...

Dives and Lazarus in the Liturgy of Lent
Before the early eighth century, the church of Rome kept the Thursdays of Lent (with the obvious exception of Holy Thursday) and the Saturdays after Ash Wednesday and Passion Sunday as “aliturgical” days. (The term aliturgical refers, of course, only to the Eucharistic liturgy, not to the Divine Office.) This is attested in the oldest liturgical bo...

The Feast of St Joseph 2025
Truly it is worthy and just... eternal God: Who didst exalt Thy most blessed Confessor Joseph with such great merits of his virtues, that by the wondrous gift of Thy grace, he merited to be made the Spouse of the most holy Virgin Mary, and be thought the father of Thy only-begotten Son, Jesus Christ, our Lord. Wherefore, venerating the day of his b...

Why Should We Build Beautiful Confessionals?
Confession is a sacrament in which we confess dark deeds, shameful sins, cowardly compromises, repeated rifts. It is something we often wish more to be done with than to do; we know we must go, that it is “good for us” as a visit to the dentist’s or the doctor’s is good for us. It might seem as if the place where we fess up, red-handed, and receive...

Both the Chaos of Jackson Pollock and the Sterility of Photorealism are Incompatible with Christianity
Unveiling the middle ground where faith, philosophy, and beauty all meet in the person of Christ, image of the invisible God.Authentic Christian art strikes a balance between abstraction and realism, rejecting the extremes of Abstract Expressionism—where meaning dissolves into unrecognizable chaos—and Photorealism, which reduces reality to soulless...

Announcing the CMAA 2025 Colloquium and Summer Courses
2025 Sacred Music Colloquium and our Summer Courses are filling up fast!The Church Music Association of American invites all its friend and supporters to come to the University of St. Thomas in Saint Paul, Minnesota for an inspiring week (or two!) of music, liturgy, and professional development.REGISTER TODAY TO SAVE YOUR SEAT!Take advantage of ear...

The Second Sunday of Lent 2025
Remember Thy compassion, o Lord, and Thy mercy, that are from of old; lest ever our enemies be lord over us; deliver us, o God of Israel, from all our distress. Ps. 24. To Thee, o Lord, have I lifted up my soul; o my God, I trust in Thee, let me not be put to shame. Glory be ... As it was... Remember Thy compassion... (A very nice recording of the...

The Myth of a Sunday with No Mass
Those who follow the traditional Divine Office and Mass closely will notice in them an unusual feature this weekend. In the Mass, the same Gospel, St Matthew’s account of the Transfiguration (17, 1-9), is read both today, the Ember Saturday, and tomorrow. In the Divine Office, there are only four antiphons taken from this Gospel, where the other Su...

“Let My Prayer Rise as Incense” - Byzantine Music for Lent
In the Byzantine Rite, the Divine Liturgy is not celebrated on the weekdays of Lent, but only on Saturdays and Sundays; an exception is made for the feast of the Annunciation. Therefore, at the Divine Liturgy on Sundays, extra loaves of bread are consecrated, and reserved for the rest of the week. On Wednesdays and Fridays, a service known as the ...

NLM Quiz #25: Where Does This Vestment Come From, And How Is It Used? The Answer
Can you guess where and how this vestment is used? I have two hints to offer: 1. It belongs to the current liturgical season. 2. It is not being used in an Eastern rite. (Apologies, but no better image of it is available.)The Answer: As I suspected would be the case, this proved to be a stumper. This vestment is a kind of stole which is used in the...

For more articles, see the NLM archives: