For years, musicians have parsed the General Instruction for guidance on how to manage the musical problem in the ordinary form. To be sure, the GIRM is a reliable guide as compared with the really-existing liturgy found in most Catholic parishes. But what if the musicians want to push forward and manner more progressive than the GIRM seems inclined to support?
Some concrete examples: a polyphonic Sanctus, which is not forbidden by law but seems vaguely discouraged by the GIRM; introducing additional Sequences besides those listed in the existing liturgical books; using the Graduale instead of the Responsorial Psalm; dropping the Mysterium Fidei; using a Kyrie in addition to the Asperges; moving the Asperges to before the Introit, etc. All of these practices are known and frequent in some parishes advancing toward the ideal but they seem not to benefit from overt backing in the GIRM.
Now, a frequent mistake is to regard the GIRM as normatively prescriptive rather than descriptive, and I gather from Canon lawyers that this is just an error. The GIRM is to be treated as a description of liturgical events in the manner in which they are expected proceed, but not a manual of rubrics that is somehow binding in a normative sense. Still, we are left without much guidance unless we look to tradition on these matters, that is to say, we look to the extraordinary form of the Roman Rite, rather than seeing the ordinary form as somehow hermetically sealed off from liturgical practice through the ages.
My question concerns the implications of the Motu Proprio on these matters. It seems to be Benedict's impulse to encourage a kind of two-way borrowing from the extraordinary to the ordinary form. The USCCB is already saying that the old rule against "mixing rites" no longer applies since the old and new are to be seen not as separate rites but as two forms of the same rite. Doesn't this suggest, then, a greater degree of liberality concerning the ordinary form than we have previously supposed? What happens, for example, to the dubium from the CDW that ruled against new form celebrations employing the old form offertory prayers? Are we to see that as entirely overruled?
Other questions present themselves. How far can we go with this? Can Introibo ad altare dei be restored? The last Gospel? Can the extraordinary Roman Canon be now placed within the new form structure? What about the old formula for distributing communion? What are the boundaries?
My apologies if these questions are a bit naive. Maybe the answer is no, no way, that's absurd, can't be done. And yet Benedict's document seems to encourage a much greater borrowing in both directions. E.g, the MP suggests that new prefaces and new saints be added in the extraordinary form on the general principle that "the two Forms of the usage of the Roman Rite can be mutually enriching."
Perhaps another way to ask the question: what the prevailing norms for borrowing between two forms of the same Rite? Is there precedent or are we exploring a completely new world here?
Sunday, July 08, 2007
Question about fluidity from Extraordinary to Ordinary
Jeffrey TuckerMore recent articles:
The Chrism Mass: Tradition, Reform and Change (Part 2) - Guest Article by Abbé Jean-Pierre HermanGregory DiPippo
This is the second part of an article by Fr Jean-Pierre Herman on the blessing of oils, which is traditionally celebrated at the Mass of the Lord’s Supper, and the recent reforms thereof; the first part was published on Tuesday. The French original was published on Sunday on the website of the Schola Sainte-Cécile as a single article. Fr Herma...
Spy Wednesday 2025Gregory DiPippo
It is worthy and just that we should always give Thee thanks, Lord, holy Father, eternal and almighty God, through Jesus Christ, Thy Son, our Lord, Who willed to suffer for the impious, and be unjustly condemned for the wicked; Who forgave the praying thief his crime, promising him Paradise by His most agreeable will, Whose death wiped away our cri...
The Chrism Mass: Tradition, Reform and Change (Part 1) - Guest Article by Abbé Jean-Pierre HermanGregory DiPippo
We are very grateful to Fr Jean-Pierre Herman for sharing with us this important article about the Chrism Mass and its recent reforms. The French original was published two days ago on the website of the Schola Sainte-Cécile as a single article; it will be published here in two parts. Fr Herman is professor of liturgy at the Good Shepherd Institute...
The 2nd Adeodatus Conference on Catholic Education, June 18-21 at Belmont Abbey CollegeDavid Clayton
Find out more and register here.This four-day gathering brings together educators, scholars, and Catholic thought leaders to explore the integral formation of students and teachers in mind, body, and spirit. Each day will focus on a distinct theme, beginning with Sound Bodies & Keen Minds, addressing topics like memory, mimesis, and freedom fro...
Guest Review of Mons. Stefan Heid’s Altar and Church: Principles of Liturgy from Early ChristianityGregory DiPippo
We are grateful to Dr Michael Coughlin, Professor of Theology at Saint John’s Seminary in Boston, for sharing with NLM this review of Monsignor Stefan Heid’s book Altar and Church: Principles of Liturgy from Early Christianity. Mons. Heid is a priest of the archdiocese of Cologne, Germany; he has taught liturgy and hagiography at the Pontific...
A Liturgical Oddity of Holy MondayGregory DiPippo
In the Missal of St Pius V, there is a very small number of days on which two Scriptural lessons are read before the Gospel: the Wednesdays of the Embertides, of the fourth week of Lent and Holy Week, and Good Friday. As I have described elsewhere, these readings are actually part of a block which is inserted into the Mass between the Kyrie and the...
Palm Sunday 2025Gregory DiPippo
Thou didst incline the heavens, and come down to the earth as one merciful. Thou didst not leave the throne of the Cherubim, Thou sat upon a colt for our sake, o Savior of the world! And the children of the Hebrews came to meet Thee, and taking palms in their hands, they blessed Thee: “Blessed art Thou who hast come to the Passion of Thy own ...
Superb Recordings of the Hymns of PassiontideGregory DiPippo
As we are about to enter Holy Week, here are two genuinely outstanding recordings of the hymns for Passiontide Vexilla Regis and Pange lingua. These come from an album released by the choir of Westminster Cathedral in October of 2023, titled Vexilla Regis: A sequence of music from Palm Sunday to Holy Saturday; the 21 tracks are also ...
The Mass of Passion Thursday - ContinuedGregory DiPippo
In yesterday’s article, I described the Roman station church of Passion Thursday as a place of exile for Eastern iconodule monks whom the persecution of the iconoclast Byzantine emperors had driven into Italy. This basilica is dedicated to St Apollinaris, the first bishop of Ravenna, who is traditionally said to have been a disciple of St Peter, se...
The Offertory Incensation, Part IIMichael P. Foley
Cardinal Hayes incensing the altar at the opening Mass for the 7th National Eucharistic Congress at the Public Auditorium in Cleveland, 1935Lost in Translation #123 When the priest incenses the altar, he recites Psalm 140, 2-4: Dirigátur, Dómine, oratio mea, sicut incensum in conspectu tuo: Elevatio manuum meárum sacrificium vespertínum. Pone, Dó...