Thursday, March 13, 2008

Cardinal Medina Estévez interviewed by Petrus

I ran into this interesting interview by way first of Rinascimento Sacro but ultimately from Bruno Volpe on Petrus.

This translation is as yet very rough and includes only excerpts. The NLM will see if it can't bring you a more refined translation.

by Bruno Volpe

VATICAN CITY - [...] Amongst the most ardent supporters of the Pope [and Summorum Pontificum] is Chilean Cardinal Jorge Arturo Medina Estévez, Prefect of the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments from 1998 to 2002, the prelate who announced to the faithful in St Peter's Square and the entire world, on 19 April 2005, the election of Benedict XVI. 'Petrus' has located him in Chile and gained an exclusive interview.

Eminence, some inside of the Church continue to oppose the Motu Proprio 'Summorum Pontificum…

"Unfortunately it is true, but it is also necessary to remember that the Mass according to the rite of St. Pius V has never been abolished and though it is currently considered 'extraordinary', it has the same right to citizenship in the Church and the same dignity as the 'Novus Ordo' of Paul VI. It should be remembered that the bishops who were opposed to Motu Proprio of Benedict XVI are perfectly free to express their opinions civilly, but, ultimately, are required to be obedient and respect for the Pope, who is the only universal pastor of the Holy Roman Church..."

Some, such as Cardinal Carlo Maria Martini, referring to the ancient rite, spoke of it in 'the sense of obsolete [chiuso]' ...

"Personally, I have always celebrated Mass with the liturgical books of St. Pius V - of which I am particularly fond - and this sense of obsolete [chiuso] I have never felt. Indeed, I will say it has been good company since my ordination."

It is said that the Tridentine rite guarantees solemnity, simplicity, mystery.

"That is undeniable. The Mass must be sober and elegant, in search of the transcendent, because it represents excellence for the sacrifice of Christ, who died and rose for us."

With Mass in the vernacular language, it certainly does not have the same solemnity as in that of St. Pius V in Latin, and with it we are witnessing significant liturgical abuses.

"The liturgy must maintain decorum and rigour without [svolazzi] or inventions, avoiding shows and inventions that, unfortunately, you are absolutely right, are today increasingly frequent. To resolve this problem, it would require a realization that the true protagonist of the Mass is always and only ever Christ and the priest."

Many accuse the Second Vatican Council, that it had not dictated a clear relation to liturgy.

"The fault is not Vatican II itself, but some of its too exuberant interpreters who believe that we should draw a line in the sand."

Eminence, what do you appreciate most about the Latin Mass of St. Pius V?

"I would say its sobriety, its elegant refinement. Certainly it has high level of transcendence, the constant search for God. But this, let me be clear, does not mean that I am against the 'Novus Ordo'. To tell the truth, consider the lectionary of the 'Novus Ordo' even richer in content than the rite of St. Pius V...".

"[Perhaps] we could find a middle ground, an agreement halfway, allowing the Eucharistic celebration with the Ordinary of the Mass according to the books of St. Pius V while using the 'Novus Ordo' lectionary..."

Cardinal, the Mass of St. Pius V also means, not only Mass in Latin: inevitably also Gregorian [chant]…

"Gregorian [chant] is the true music of the Church..."

More recent articles:


The Feast and Sunday of St John Climacus
In the Byzantine liturgy, each of the Sundays of Lent has a special commemoration attached to it. The first Sunday is known as the Sunday of Orthodoxy, because it commemorates the defeat of iconoclasm and the restoration of the orthodox belief in the use of icons; many churches have a procession in which the clergy and faithful carry the icons, as...

The Story of Susanna in the Liturgy of Lent
In the Roman Rite, the story of Susanna is read as the epistle of Saturday of the third week of Lent, the longest epistle of the entire year. This episode is not in the Hebrew text of Daniel, but in the manuscripts of the Septuagint, it appears as the beginning of the book, probably because in verse 45 Daniel is called a “younger man”, whic...

A New Edition of the Monastic Breviary Available Soon
The printing house of the Monastère Saint-Benoît in Brignole, France, Éditions Pax inter Spinas, is pleased to announce the re-publication of the two volumes of the last edition (1963) of the traditional Latin Monastic Breviary.The Breviary contains all that is necessary to pray the complete Monastic Divine Office of Matins, Lauds, Prime, Terce, S...

A Mid-Western Saint from Rome: Guest Article by Mr Sean Pilcher
Thanks once again to our friend Mr Sean Pilcher, this time for sharing with us this account of the relics of a Saint from the Roman catacombs, which were brought to the cathedral of Dubuque, Iowa, in the 19th century. Mr Pilcher is the director of Sacra: Relics of the Saints (sacrarelics.org), an apostolate that promotes education about relics, and...

Fons et Culmen Sacred Liturgy Summit - July 1–4, Menlo Park, California
You are cordially invited to the Fons et Culmen Sacred Liturgy Summit, which will be held from July 1-4, in Menlo Park, California!Fons et Culmen Sacred Liturgy Summit gathers together Catholics who love Christ, the Church, and the Church’s sacred liturgical tradition for: - the solemn celebration of the Mass and Vespers; - insightful talks on...

A Lenten Station Mass in the Roman Forum
Today’s Mass is one of the series instituted by Pope St Gregory II (715-31) when he abolished the older custom of the Roman Rite, by which the Thursdays of Lent were “aliturgical” days on which no Mass was celebrated. The station appointed for the day is at the basilica of Ss Cosmas and Damian, which was constructed by Pope St Felix IV (526-30) in ...

Do Priests or Religious Need Special Permission to Pray a Pre-55 Breviary?
On occasion, I receive an email like the following (in this case, from a seminarian): “Do you happen to know of any sources/authoritative references which you could point me to that explain why praying the Pre-55 Breviary definitely satisfies the canonical obligation for clerics or religious? As I am strongly desirous of the Pre-55 Liturgy, I ...

Early Bird Registration Discount for CMAA Colloquium Ends March 31st!
Join us this summer for world-class training in the Church’s treasury of sacred music.Early bird registration discount ($50 for colloquium, $50 for Vocal Intensive course, $150 off for Chant Intensive) ends March 31st!Here’s a special invitation from our new president, Fr. Robert Pasley.The Church Music Association of America is pleased to announc...

The Annunciation 2025: Dante and the Virgin Mary
The specific date of birth of the great poet Dante Alighieri (1265-1321) is unknown, but this Thursday, March 27th, is the anniversary of his baptism, which took place during the Easter vigil of 1266. The language which we call “Italian” today originated as the dialect of his native region of Tuscany (more specifically, of the city of Florence, but...

The Messenger Angel
Anonymous, the Archangel Gabriel, depicted on the predella of the high altar at the subsidiary church of Pesenbach, Upper Austria, 1495In the traditional Roman calendar, the feast days of saints are sometimes clustered together to form archipelagos of holiness that allow the faithful to meditate longer on a sacred mystery. These archipelagos do not...

For more articles, see the NLM archives: